The Kenntnisprüfung commission: who examines you?
How section 37 describes the state commission and what that means for your answers.
Context
Three people sit across from you, not one anonymous examining machine: who chairs the commission, who else examines alongside them, and how those roles are divided changes what you should actually focus on in your answers.
KP is taken as a state exam before a state examination commission.
Structure of the Exam Commission
The commission consists of a chair and two additional members who jointly judge your performance. The chair doesn't just lead formally — they also examine you directly on content, so you need to respond to several clinical perspectives at once, not just a single opinion.
Professors, teaching staff, or specialist physicians can be appointed as examiners, each assessing the case from their own clinical practice. That means follow-up questions can come from different clinical angles rather than a single specialty, which changes how you should frame your reasoning.
- The commission consists of a chair and two additional members.
- The chair leads the exam and must examine personally.
- Professors, teachers, or specialists can be appointed as examiners.
Source:Medical Licensing Regulation, section 37
At a glance
- The commission consists of a chair and two additional members.
- The chair leads the exam and must examine personally.
- Professors, teachers, or specialists can be appointed as examiners.
Practicing Answers That Invite Follow-Up
Reciting a memorized presentation falls apart the moment a follow-up question departs from the script. Train answers that can adapt to questions instead, and justify your decisions precisely enough that a specialist physician can follow your reasoning step by step, rather than just hearing the conclusion.
- Practise answers with follow-up questions rather than memorised speeches.
- Justify decisions so specialists can examine your reasoning.
Misconceptions About the Commission
Some picture the exam commission as a single strict authority, or assume that detailed subject knowledge alone decides the outcome. Both ideas fall short and often lead to the wrong kind of preparation.
- Misconception: Only the chair asks the questions that matter. — In fact: The chair must examine personally, but the two other members also actively assess your performance.
- Misconception: Detailed subject knowledge alone determines the result. — In fact: The commission also checks whether you can justify decisions so specialists from different fields can follow your reasoning.
Composition Can Vary
Which specialties are actually represented on the commission, and how the two additional members are chosen, depends on the specific examination body and state. Who is appointed as an examiner in your individual case is decided by the responsible Landesärztekammer or Approbationsbehörde.
Don't rely on accounts describing a specific commission in a different state. Ask your responsible authority in good time how the commission for your exam date is typically composed and which specialties are regularly represented there, so you can prepare for plausible follow-up questions from the right clinical angle.
Practicing Follow-Up Questions in Role-Play
A role-play simulation of the exam situation lets you practice responding to changing follow-up questions from different clinical angles as often as you like — as preparation for real questioning, not a substitute for the commission itself.
Ready for exam-like cases?
Practise patient presentation, report work, and commission questions in a structured KP simulation.
Start simulation